Commentary:
This time, decision is to present analysis based on free AI tools willing to cooperate within their limits. Got the answers from tools like Perflexity, Powerdrill etc.
Tools like Julius, Grok, Copilot, Gemini, Deepseek failed or declined.
The AI reports are attached below.
PERFLEXITY:
Based on the file attached, Please give detailed analysis report as to best mutual funds to invest for short term say next 3 months, medium term say next 1 year, and long term say next 3 years. Also highlight the divergence of performance leadership across various timelines from 1 week thru 20 years. Also comment as to whether taking an average performance across all timelines and then choosing the top funds based on this average will help for investments ahead across different timelines mentioned like short term, medium term and long term
Based on the detailed mutual fund performance data extracted from the file "Combined-07-Jun-2025.xlsx," here is a comprehensive analysis of the best mutual funds to invest in for short-term (next 3 months), medium-term (next 1 year), and long-term (next 3 years) horizons. Additionally, the analysis covers the divergence in performance leadership across various timelines and comments on the strategy of using average performance across all timelines for fund selection.
1. Best Mutual Funds for Different Investment Horizons
Short Term (Next 3 Months)
For a 3-month horizon, the key metric is the 3-month return (%) and its rank among peers.
· Top performers in 3-month returns:
o Motilal Oswal Nifty India Defence Index Fund - Direct Plan: 61.8% (Rank 1/105)
o Motilal Oswal Nifty India Defence ETF: 61.77% (Rank 1/121)
o Groww Nifty India Defence ETF: 61.41% (Rank 3/121)
o Aditya Birla Sun Life Nifty India Defence Index Fund - Direct Plan: 61.47% (Rank 2/105)
o Groww Nifty India Defence ETF FoF - Direct Plan: 61.38% (Rank 3/105)
These funds, focused on the India Defence sector, have shown exceptional short-term performance, indicating strong momentum and sectoral strength.
· Other notable funds with strong 3-month returns:
o Motilal Oswal Nifty Capital Market Index Fund - Direct Plan: 51.08% (Rank 5/105)
o DSP World Gold FoF - Direct Plan: 31.04% (Rank 1/61)
o Tata Nifty Capital Markets Index Fund - Direct Plan: 51.18% (Rank 4/105)
Medium Term (Next 1 Year)
For a 1-year horizon, 1-year return (%) and rank are the focus.
· Top performers in 1-year returns:
o DSP World Gold FoF - Direct Plan: 67.73% (Rank 1/61)
o Motilal Oswal Nifty India Defence Index Fund - Direct Plan: 29.54% (Rank 1/85)
o Motilal Oswal Nifty India Defence ETF: 29.53% (Rank 1/100)
o Groww Nifty India Defence ETF FoF - Direct Plan: 29.11% (Rank 2/85)
o Aditya Birla Sun Life Nifty India Defence Index Fund - Direct Plan: 29.06% (Rank 3/85)
The Defence sector funds continue to lead, with gold-focused funds like DSP World Gold FoF also performing strongly, reflecting a blend of sectoral and commodity plays for medium-term gains.
· Other funds with good 1-year returns:
o HDFC Defence Fund - Direct Plan: 25.67% (Rank 1/59)
o Mirae Asset NYSE FANG+ ETF: 35.39% (Rank 6/67)
Long Term (Next 3 Years)
For a 3-year horizon, 3-year return (%) and rank are critical.
· Top performers in 3-year returns:
o Motilal Oswal Nifty India Defence Index Fund - Direct Plan: Leading but data not explicitly available for 3 years.
o DSP World Gold FoF - Direct Plan: 23.55%
o Invesco India Mid Cap Fund - Direct Plan: 31.87% (Rank 1/42)
o Bandhan Small Cap Fund - Direct Plan: 35.14%
o Motilal Oswal Large and Midcap Fund - Direct Plan: 33.78%
o LIC MF Infrastructure Fund - Direct Plan: 33.27%
o Motilal Oswal Midcap Fund - Direct Plan: 34.19%
o Sundaram Long Term Micro Cap Tax Advantage Fund Series VI - Direct Plan: 23.95%
Mid-cap and small-cap funds, along with infrastructure and sector-specific funds, show strong 3-year returns, suggesting these categories are suitable for long-term growth.
2. Divergence of Performance Leadership Across Timelines
· Short-term (1 week to 3 months): Sector-specific funds like Defence and Capital Markets ETFs dominate with very high returns and top ranks. For example, Motilal Oswal Nifty India Defence funds consistently rank 1st in 1-month and 3-month returns.
· Medium-term (6 months to 1 year): Gold funds and sectoral funds (Defence, Financial Services) show leadership. DSP World Gold FoF leads 1-year returns, indicating commodity plays gain traction over medium terms.
· Long-term (3 years to 20 years): Leadership shifts towards diversified mid-cap, small-cap, and infrastructure funds. These funds have consistent returns over longer periods, reflecting stable growth and compounding.
· Volatility in rankings: Some funds that lead in short-term (e.g., Defence ETFs) do not have long-term data or show moderate long-term performance. Conversely, some mid-cap and small-cap funds with moderate short-term returns excel in long-term horizons.
3. Analysis of Using Average Performance Across All Timelines for Fund Selection
· The file ranks funds based on an "All Timeline Average Return," which aggregates returns across multiple periods (1 week, 1 month, 3 months, 6 months, 1 year, 3 years, 5 years, etc.).
· Advantages:
o Provides a balanced view of fund performance across different market cycles.
o Helps identify funds with consistent performance rather than just short-term spikes.
o Suitable for investors who want a one-stop metric to shortlist funds.
· Limitations:
o Averaging can dilute the impact of recent performance, which is critical for short-term investments.
o Long-term averages may overshadow funds that are currently in strong momentum phases.
o Funds with no data in some timelines (e.g., new funds) may be unfairly penalized.
· Conclusion:
o Using average performance across all timelines is a good starting point for medium to long-term investment decisions, identifying funds with consistent track records.
o For short-term investments (3 months), it's better to prioritize recent performance metrics (3-month, 1-month returns) rather than an average that includes long-term data.
o For medium-term (1 year), a blend of recent and 1-year returns with average performance can be effective.
o For long-term (3 years+), average performance and long-term returns should be weighted more heavily.
Summary Recommendations
Investment Horizon | Recommended Fund Types | Top Funds Examples | Notes |
Short Term (3 months) | Sector-specific ETFs (Defence, Capital Markets) | Motilal Oswal Nifty India Defence Index Fund, Motilal Oswal Nifty Capital Market Index Fund | Focus on recent strong momentum and sectoral trends |
Medium Term (1 year) | Commodity funds (Gold), Sectoral funds (Defence, Financial Services) | DSP World Gold FoF, HDFC Defence Fund, Mirae Asset NYSE FANG+ ETF | Blend of sector and commodity exposure for balanced growth |
Long Term (3 years) | Mid-cap, Small-cap, Infrastructure, Diversified equity funds | Invesco India Mid Cap Fund, Bandhan Small Cap Fund, LIC MF Infrastructure Fund | Emphasis on consistent growth and compounding |
This analysis is based on the detailed returns and ranks across timelines provided in the attached data file[1].
POWERDRILL:
Top-Performing Funds Across Investment Horizons
Short-Term Funds (Weeks to Months)
- Top Funds: For short-term investments, the leading funds include Motilal Oswal Nifty Realty ETF, Motilal Oswal Nifty Capital Market Index Fund - Direct Plan, Motilal Oswal Nifty India Defence Index Fund - Direct Plan, and DSP World Gold FoF - Direct Plan.
Medium-Term Funds (1-3 Years)
- Top Funds: In the medium term, the top-performing funds are DSP World Gold FoF - Direct Plan and Mirae Asset NYSE FANG+ ETF FoF - Direct Plan.
Long-Term Funds (5+ Years)
- Top Funds: For long-term investment horizons, the top funds to consider are Quant Small Cap Fund - Direct Plan, Nippon India Small Cap Fund - Direct Plan, Nippon India ETF Nifty Next 50 Junior BeES, and Nippon India ETF Nifty Bank BeES.
Conclusion and Insights
- Diverse Fund Performance: The analysis reveals that different funds excel across various investment horizons. Short-term gains are prominent in realty and defense sector funds, while medium-term focuses lean towards global and tech-focused ETFs. Long-term investments favor small-cap and diversified ETFs.
- Fund Specialization: Each fund appears to have a specialization that dictates its performance over different time frames. For example, realty and capital market funds show strong short-term returns, while small-cap funds demonstrate long-term growth potential.
- Investment Strategy: Investors should align their fund choices with their investment timeline and risk tolerance. Short-term investors might consider the Motilal Oswal and DSP funds, while those with a long-term outlook may prefer Quant and Nippon India funds.
--------------------------------------
Blog: NatsFunCorner! on Blogger
https://natsfuncorner.blogspot.com/
Other relevant Social Network Platform links:
Whatsapp Group: This whatsapp group is a peer group, people active in investment and trading (including day trading) are here, exchanging their insight and views. Please note that there is no room for promotional participation here.
https://chat.whatsapp.com/IuzkVAHgn1jJ20ZmB8m9Vz
FB: https://www.facebook.com/nupadhya/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/nupadhya
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/natsupadhya/
Twitter (X): https://twitter.com/nupadhya
LinkedIn: https: https://www.linkedin.com/in/nupadhya/
Disclaimer:
- This is not a solicitation for mutual fund investment nor an advice. It is only an insight to help investment decisions based on the free MF performance data downloaded from Value Research. Investment decisions are only yours to make.
- Mutual fund investments are subjected to market risk. Read the propsectus of a mutual fund for all the risk information associated prior to investment.
- The author can not be responsible for the ommissions or errors in the data from Value Research or the data processing errors if any by the author.
- All your investment decisions need to be based on your decision finally, with no blame to anyone else later.
No comments:
Post a Comment